188 Comments
тна Return to thread

Love Me Do written in 1958.

PS I Love You written in Hamburg in 1962

From Me To You, on a bus from York to Shrewsbury. Feb '63

She Loves You, hotel in Newcastle, 6/26/63,

All My Loving, written on a bus on tour,.

I could go on.

Expand full comment

https://youtu.be/0FnVOTmKoqU

Interesting statement.."strictly speaking a little bit impossible"

Expand full comment

He did NOT say it didn't happen. SHEESH!! You still haven't explained the claim that they didn't write on the road and said so compared to all the tunes i came up with even by Spring '64 which were written... on the road.

Expand full comment

He did laugh at the thought

Expand full comment

The claim, I will need time to work on to present, if you don't want to research the channel. It makes sense to me, but I will study it, as time allows, to be able to post here effectively

Expand full comment

BBC interview with John and Paul August 1966. Paul- "The only time we need to force ourselves to write songs is when an Lp or film comes up." He also said "We don't write between lps normally, maybe one or two, then we write a great big batch".

Expand full comment

By which point they were well-established. Before that point, they wrote whenever, wherever, and had started doing so in the late '50s. The notion that they didn't play on their own albums or write their own tunes is pure rubbish, and the fact that some people not only buy such trash but clutch on to it desperately is an artifact of full digital conditions, which Eric frequently discusses. Comes from the same place as Flat Earth flatulence.

Expand full comment

Suit yourself. Personally I am not desperately clinging onto anything. I didn't want to believe it, but I did come to see that the Cinderella story we were fed it just not true.

Expand full comment

As Eric pointed out to you very well, the whole story of the "fake Paul" is rancid crap, just like the entire "Tavistock creationist" myth. The fact that you cling it says enough. Nice chatting with you, i'm off to watch porn or, even better, a drying paint webcam.

Expand full comment

Please do

Expand full comment

Furthermore, it was my own awareness detection that first struck a off note about "Paul" from non-digital magazines over fifty years ago.

Expand full comment

Question, B -- to what extent are you musically trained, proficient? Do you play an instrument, write or sing?

Expand full comment

I am not trained musically. I am working to teach myself piano. I would say I might be somewhere between Pre-K and Kindergarten level.

Expand full comment
Comment deleted
Aug 31, 2023
Comment deleted
Expand full comment

I been trying to answer the questions you asked.

Expand full comment

I am trying to find a short clip of the interview with John and Paul in the early 60's to post. One of them says something like "we wrote in batches" as opposed to out of studio time. One of them said 'we may write one or two. "

Expand full comment